How Many Candidates Should You Really Have to Interview?

How Many Candidates Should You Really Have to Interview to Find the Right Person?

You’ve blocked out an hour in your diary, prepared your interview questions and made time in an already busy schedule to meet a potential new employee.

But ten minutes into the interview, you realise something isn’t right.

The candidate doesn’t have the experience you need, doesn’t understand your industry or simply isn’t suited to the role.

And you’re left wondering why you’re sitting in this interview in the first place.

It’s frustrating for hiring managers, but it’s equally frustrating for candidates who have invested their time preparing for an opportunity that was never a good match.

So, how do you avoid wasting time interviewing the wrong candidates?

The answer isn’t necessarily to interview more people. It’s to work with a recruitment partner who understands your business well enough to identify the right people before they ever reach your interview room.

 

The Challenge: Too Many Interviews, Too Few Suitable Candidates

One of the biggest frustrations we hear from hiring managers is the amount of time spent interviewing candidates who simply aren’t right for the role.

And in specialist sectors such as Financial Markets, the challenge can be even greater.

A candidate might have the right qualifications, an impressive CV and experience in the industry, but that doesn’t automatically mean they’re right for your organisation.

Different businesses have different investment philosophies, operating environments, team structures and expectations.

A candidate who thrives in one environment might not be successful in another.

When recruiters don’t understand these differences, hiring managers often end up doing the screening themselves.

And that defeats one of the main reasons for using a recruitment agency in the first place.

 

The Approach: Understanding the Client Before Searching for Candidates

At The Talent Experts, our Head of Financial Markets, Claudette, has built her recruitment approach around understanding the businesses she recruits for.

That means going beyond the job description.

It’s about understanding the organisation’s culture, the team dynamics, the technical requirements and what makes someone successful in that particular environment.

It’s also about building relationships with clients over time.

The better a recruiter understands a business, the better equipped they are to recognise candidates who will genuinely fit, rather than simply ticking the boxes on a job specification.

And this is particularly important in Financial Markets, where specialist knowledge and an understanding of the industry can make an enormous difference to the quality of a shortlist.

The objective isn’t to present as many candidates as possible. It’s to present the right candidates.

 

The Outcome: Fewer Interviews and Better-Matched Candidates

One of Claudette’s clients recently shared this feedback about working with her:
“Claudette is the best financial market recruitment agent in SA. understand our business and I never have to interview more than three people making my life a lot easier.”

And another client independently highlighted exactly the same approacch:
“Claudette understands us and her matches are great. She sends quality candidates that fit our requirements, not just merely forward of CV’s. By the time we get the profile of the candidate, the groundwork has been done. I Would happily recommend her to any employer.”

Two different clients, but a remarkably similar message.

For the first client, the value is that they rarely need to interview more than three people.

For the second, it’s knowing that by the time a candidate’s profile reaches their desk, the initial groundwork has already been done.

Both experiences highlight something important: a well-screened shortlist doesn’t just make recruitment easier. It gives hiring managers confidence that their time is being spent on candidates who genuinely warrant consideration.

 

What Should Hiring Managers Expect from a Specialist Recruitment Partner?

If you’re working with a recruitment agency and regularly finding that the candidates you’re interviewing aren’t suitable, there are a few things worth considering.

  1. Does your recruiter really understand your business?
    A good recruitment partner should understand more than the vacancy you’re trying to fill.
    They should know what your business does, how your teams operate, what your culture looks like and what makes someone successful in your organisation.
    That understanding often comes from building a relationship over time, not simply receiving a job specification.
  2. Do they understand your industry?
    In specialist sectors like Financial Markets, industry knowledge matters.
    Understanding the differences between roles, technical requirements and business environments allows recruiters to assess candidates more effectively.
    It’s difficult to identify the right talent if you don’t fully understand what that talent actually does.
  3. Are they screening candidates or simply forwarding CVs?
    There’s a big difference between finding someone whose CV matches a job description and assessing whether that person is genuinely suitable.
    A strong recruiter should be able to explain why they’ve recommended each candidate, including how their experience aligns with the role and any areas that may need further exploration.
    As Claudette’s second client points out, the groundwork should already have been done before a profile is presented.
  4. Are you receiving quality or quantity?
    More candidates don’t necessarily mean better recruitment.
    A shortlist of three carefully selected professionals can be far more valuable than ten candidates who only partially meet the requirements.
    The goal should be to make the hiring decision easier, not create more work for the hiring manager.

 

The Real Value of Specialist Recruitment

Recruitment success is often measured by how quickly a vacancy is filled.

And while speed certainly matters, we believe there’s another measure that’s just as important.

How much time and effort did the recruitment partner save the client along the way?

What makes these two testimonials particularly meaningful is that neither client is talking about the number of CVs received.

They’re talking about the quality of the candidates, the understanding of their businesses and the work that happens before an interview is ever scheduled.

And that’s what good specialist recruitment should deliver.

Not a mountain of CVs.

Not an endless interview process.

Just the right people, carefully selected, so hiring managers can spend less time searching and more time running their businesses. 💛

Scroll to Top